Nuda propiedad: Everything you need to know about this real estate right

The bare ownership is a legal concept that defines the ownership of a property without the right to use and enjoy it. This right is divided between the bare ownership and the usufructuary, creating a specific relationship between both parties. In Spain, the bare ownership has important implications in inheritances, donations and real estate transactions. Understanding its characteristics, rights and obligations is essential for any property-related transaction.

Definition and Concept of Nuda Propiedad

The bare ownership is a legal figure that implies the division of rights over a property. This segmentation allows a person to have the ownership of a property without possessing the right of use and enjoyment, which is assigned to another party.

Differences between bare ownership and freehold ownership

Full ownership is characterized by the accumulation of all rights over a property, including use, enjoyment and disposition. In contrast, bare ownership occurs when these rights are divided. The key differences are detailed below:

• Rights of Use: While an owner with full ownership may use the property freely, the bare owner may not exercise this right until the usufruct is extinguished.
• Powers of Disposal: The bare owner may sell or mortgage his right over the bare property, but with limitations on the ability to use the property.
• Durability of Ownership: The bare ownership can be for life or for a determined period of time; however, once the usufruct is exhausted, the bare owner recovers full rights.

Nuda Propiedad and Usufruct: Distinct Rights

The usufruct is the right that allows a person to use an asset owned by another, with the commitment to preserve its nature. In the case of the bare ownership, the rights and duties of both parties are differentiated:

• Usufructuary: Enjoys the property, has the responsibility to maintain it and must respect its integrity.
• Nudo Proprietor: Has the right of ownership, but its enjoyment is conditioned until the usufruct is extinguished. He can make decisions on the sale or mortgage, always respecting the usufruct in force.

Nuda Propiedad en el Contexto Inheritance in the Real Estate Context

The bare ownership plays an essential role in real estate, especially in estate planning and succession issues. This mechanism allows owners to manage their wealth more effectively. Some relevant aspects include:

• Inheritance: Facilitates the transfer of the estate to heirs, allowing the surviving spouse or children to keep the use of the property for a certain period of time.
• Donations: It is used as a tool to transmit assets to descendants. Parents can donate the bare property while maintaining the usufruct to guarantee their own enjoyment.
• Investments: Buying bare ownership offers opportunities in real estate. Investors can acquire assets at a lower price, hoping to regain full ownership when the usufruct is extinguished.

Advantages and Disadvantages of the Buda Propiedad

The figure of bare ownership has both positive and negative aspects that are essential to consider. Its exhaustive analysis allows a better understanding of how to optimize its use and avoid future problems.

Estate and Succession Advantages

One of the main advantages of contemplating the bare ownership is the estate planning it allows. This structure facilitates the transfer of property to heirs, while ensuring the usufruct for the surviving spouse or the original owner. Thus, the right to enjoy the property is preserved even after the death of the owner, guaranteeing economic stability for the usufructuary.

This is especially valuable in family contexts, as it avoids conflicts between heirs and ensures that the property remains within the family nucleus, protecting loved ones who depend on the property for their residence.

Investments and Economic Profitability

The economic benefits are another aspect to highlight in the bare ownership. People who decide to invest can acquire the bare ownership of a property at a lower cost, since the usufruct is in the hands of another person. This situation gives investors the opportunity to obtain long-term income once the usufruct ends, which may be of interest to those seeking to increase their wealth without a high initial outlay.

• Access to higher value properties at reduced prices.
• Opportunity to diversify investments in the real estate sector.
• Generation of future income through the acquisition of real estate.

Owner Knot Limitations and Responsibilities

Despite the advantages, the bare ownership also entails a series of limitations. The naked owner cannot enjoy the immediate use of the property until the usufruct is extinguished. This situation can be a significant disadvantage for those seeking immediate use of their investment. Investing in bare ownership is, therefore, a decision that must be carefully weighed.

On the other hand, the bare owner also assumes responsibilities that may be onerous. Being the legal owner of the property, he is responsible for its maintenance and upkeep. This implies the obligation to maintain the property in adequate conditions, as well as the payment of associated taxes, such as the Real Estate Tax (IBI). These costs must be considered as they may impact the total profitability of the investment.

• Responsibility for maintaining the condition of the property.
• Obligation to pay taxes related to the property.
• Limitations on decisions affecting the usufructuary.

How to Acquire the Nuda Propiedad

The acquisition of the bare ownership can be carried out in several ways. The most common options include inheritance, gifts with reservation of usufruct and sale. Below is a breakdown of each of these methods.

Inheritance and Estate Transfer

One of the most frequent ways to obtain the bare ownership is through inheritance. In this context, the heirs may receive ownership of a property that belonged to a deceased relative. In many cases, the surviving spouse may choose to reserve the usufruct of the property, which allows him or her to continue living in the property while the children or other heirs become bare owners.

This type of property transfer is particularly useful to ensure the stability of the family home and to maintain continuity in the use of the property, while distributing the property rights among the heirs. The bare ownership, in this case, becomes a succession planning tool that allows to manage the legacy efficiently.

Donation with Reservation of Usufruct

Another common method of acquiring the bare ownership is by donation with reservation of usufruct. In this scenario, the donor transfers ownership of the property to a donee, but reserves the right of usufruct for life over the property. This type of agreement is especially useful for parents who wish to secure their estate, while continuing to enjoy the use and enjoyment of the property.

By making a donation of this type, the donor is guaranteed economic security and can live in the property without losing the real property. At the same time, the donee acquires the bare ownership and, once the usufruct is extinguished, will be able to exercise full rights over the property. This practice not only helps in estate planning, but also offers tax advantages in certain cases.

Sale of the bare property

In recent years, the sale of the bare property has gained popularity, especially among elderly people who have no heirs or who wish to obtain additional income. In this case, the owner of the property sells his or her bare property to a third party, reserving the usufruct for as long as he or she wishes to live in the property.

This transaction is usually carried out at a lower price than the market price, given that the buyer assumes the status of the bare owner without being able to enjoy the property until the extinction of the usufruct. However, it offers a viable solution for those seeking to convert a real estate asset into liquidity, while maintaining a level of security in their home. This type of agreement may involve a detailed financial and legal analysis for both parties.

Rights of the Owner Knot

The bare owner maintains a series of rights despite the limitations imposed by the usufruct. This section details the rights to which he is entitled, as well as the responsibilities and capacities he has in relation to the property.

Property Law and Sale

The bare owner is the legal owner of the property, which implies that he has ownership rights, although these are restricted due to the usufruct. The position of the bare owner does not prevent the bare owner from exercising certain actions on the property.

Sale of the bare property

The possibility of selling the bare property is a viable option for the naked owner. He can transfer his right to a third party, although this sale usually reflects a price lower than the full value of the property. The new bare owner will assume the same situation, being aware that the usufruct will remain in force.

Right to Mortgage the Nuda Propiedad

Another significant prerogative is the power to mortgage the bare property. This right allows the bare ownership to use the property as collateral to obtain financing. The possibility of accessing loans is fundamental in difficult economic situations, allowing the owner to meet his financial needs without losing ownership of the property.

Works and Improvements

The bare owner has the right to carry out works and improvements on the property, although he must take into account the usufruct and the right of use of the usufructuary. All actions must be carried out responsibly and with consideration of the impact they may have on the property and its enjoyment.

Permitted Works and Improvements

The works to be carried out must not impair the usufructuary's ability to enjoy the property. Therefore, it is important for the bare owner to prioritize the maintenance and upkeep of the property in proper condition. Ornamental or maintenance improvements are generally acceptable, provided that they do not interfere with the use enjoyed by the usufructuary.

Approval of the Usufructuary

In cases of significant improvements, the bare owner should consider the need to obtain the approval of the usufructuary. This is because any drastic change could seriously affect the usufructuary's use of the property. Communication between both parties is key to avoid conflicts and ensure a harmonious coexistence with respect to the property.

Restitution of Freehold

Once the usufruct is extinguished, the bare owner automatically recovers full ownership of the property. This is a fundamental right: he/she recovers not only the ownership, but also the rights of use and enjoyment over the property.

Obligations of the Knot Owner

The bare owner, although he has the ownership of the property, has a series of responsibilities that he must fulfill during the term of the usufruct. These obligations are essential to maintain the condition of the property and to respect the rights of the usufructuary.

Maintenance and upkeep of the property

The first obligation assumed by the bare owner is to ensure the proper maintenance of the property. This implies performing the necessary tasks so that the property does not suffer deterioration and maintains its value over time. Maintenance activities may include:

• Structural and installation repairs.
• Cleaning and maintenance of common or private spaces.
• Verification of the status of basic services, such as water and electricity.

The responsibility to maintain the property in good condition extends to all areas of the property, and it is essential that they are carried out regularly. Any neglect in maintenance could result in a grievance to the usufructuary, who has the right to enjoy a property that is in good condition.

Payment of Taxes

The bare owner is also responsible for paying certain taxes related to the property. This translates into a financial burden that must be borne by being in possession of the title. The main taxes to consider include:

Real Estate Tax

One of the most relevant taxes is the Real Estate Tax (IBI). This tax is annual and is calculated based on the cadastral value of the property. Although the usufructuary has the right to use and enjoy the property, the responsibility for payment falls on the bare owner, who must manage these payments punctually to avoid penalties or surcharges.

Taxes and Fees

In addition, the joint owner must take care of other taxes and fees that may arise. These may include garbage fees, contributions for municipal services or specific taxes depending on the autonomous community. It is essential to be aware of all fiscal commitments to avoid administrative problems in the future.

Respecting the Use of the Beneficial Owner

Although the bare owner has ownership rights over the property, he must respect the usufructuary's ability to enjoy the property. This means that he cannot interfere with the usufructuary's use and enjoyment of the property. This obligation includes the following aspects:

• Not to interrupt the use of the property by the usufructuary.
• Do not make decisions that alter the conditions of enjoyment.
• Respect the privacy and rights of the beneficial owner in his or her residence.

Respect for the usufructuary is not only a legal issue, but also an ethical one, since it establishes a balanced relationship between the parties involved. Ignoring this obligation may lead to conflicts that affect the coexistence and proper maintenance of the property.

Extinction of Usufruct

The extinction of the usufruct refers to the process by which the right of usufruct ends, giving back to the bare owner the full availability of the property. This phenomenon may occur for various reasons, each with particular characteristics that affect the parties involved.

Death of the Usufructuary

One of the most common reasons for the extinction of the usufruct is the death of the usufructuary. This event immediately terminates the right of use and enjoyment of the property, allowing the bare owner to recover his full rights. Consequently, the bare owner can begin to enjoy the property without restrictions, assuming full control of the property. This aspect is important in inheritance situations, since, through the death of the usufructuary, the property will pass in its entirety to the ownership of the bare owner.

Compliance with the Established Deadline

Another cause that may lead to the extinction of the usufruct is the expiration of the term established in the usufruct contract. If the usufruct was created for a certain period, at the end of this term, the usufruct right will be automatically extinguished. This ensures that the beneficial owner can enjoy the property once the agreed time period has expired. Clarity of the terms of the usufruct is crucial to avoid misunderstandings between the parties.

Sale of Usufruct

The usufructuary has the option to sell his usufructuary right. This transaction can be beneficial to both parties, since the bare owner can choose to acquire the usufruct and, consequently, regain full ownership of the property. This agreement is carried out through a purchase contract detailing the terms and conditions of the sale.

Purchase by Owner's Knot

In the event that the bare owner decides to acquire the usufructuary right from the usufructuary, this will allow him to immediately obtain full rights to the property. The purchase can be made at a price negotiated between the parties and formalized by drawing up a contract. This option is especially useful when both parties seek an amicable resolution and wish to avoid future conflicts.

Compliance with Resolving Conditions

Sometimes, the usufruct can be constituted under certain resolutory conditions. This implies that if a certain circumstance is met, the usufruct will be automatically extinguished. For example, a usufruct could be granted until the bare owner marries. The fulfillment of this condition would result in the extinction of the usufruct immediately, thus allowing the bare owner to regain full control of the property.

Legal Aspects of the Nuda Propiedad

The bare ownership is subject to various regulations that govern its operation and that are essential for the proper management and protection of the rights of the parties involved. The most relevant legal aspects related to this concept are analyzed below.

Regulation in the Civil Code

The Spanish Civil Code provides a broad legal framework covering ownership and real rights, including bare ownership and usufruct. These rights are mainly regulated in the articles that focus on ownership, allowing to define the relationship between the bare owner and the usufructuary. It is crucial to understand that the legislation establishes duties and rights that must be respected in order to avoid litigation. In particular, the articles that mention the constitution, execution and extinction of the usufruct are of vital importance.

Counseling of Specialized Attorneys

Due to the complexity of bare ownership and the legal implications it entails, having the advice of attorneys specialized in real estate law is essential. These professionals can provide detailed information on best practices and strategies for securing the rights of both bare ownership and usufructuary rights. In addition, they can assist in interpreting legal clauses, drafting contracts and handling any disputes that may arise.

Conflicts and Legal Resolution

The existence of a division of rights can sometimes generate disputes between joint owners and usufructuaries. These disputes may include disagreements over the use of the property, improvement works and the fulfillment of mutual obligations. In the event of a dispute, the parties involved may resort to the courts for a resolution. It is advisable to first attempt to resolve disputes through alternative methods, such as mediation, before proceeding judicially.

• Conflicts over the right of use: these may arise when the usufructuary and the bare owner have different views on how the property should be used.
• Disagreements over maintenance: the responsibility for maintaining the property in good condition can lead to disputes, especially if one party perceives that the other is not fulfilling its duties.
• Modifications and investments: if the bare owner wishes to make improvements, he needs the approval of the usufructuary to ensure that these do not affect his right of enjoyment.

It is essential to bear in mind that the resolution of any conflict related to the bare ownership must be approached in a careful and professional manner, to ensure that the rights of both parties are respected as stipulated by current legislation.

If you are interested in our help. Contact us here.